Members of Action Palestine swamped the vehicle of Mrs Talya Lador-Fresher at the exit of the Renolds Building on North Campus, temporarily preventing her leaving the premises.
The visit came just over six weeks after Mrs Lador-Fresher’s initial visit was postponed amidst fierce debate and the threat of volatile protests.
Embassy officials said the postponed talk was able to go ahead this time around as a result of the venue change. The move from the Student’s Union to University property at the Renold building meant that campus security was available in the auditorium.
The Deputy Ambassador expressed “serious concerns about physical abuse” had the talk gone ahead in the Students’ Union.
An entourage of private security guards escorted the Deputy Ambassador to and from the venue.
Mrs Lador-Fresher has recently visited several other universities in the UK, aware of a prominent student movement against Israeli policy on Palestine.
Speaking to Student Direct: Mancunian, Labor-Fresher said: “It’s very important for me, and for us at the embassy, to have the Israeli voice coming across to young people in this country and to the new intelligentsia.
“Unfortunately the last time I was scheduled to come here I had to cancel because of the amount of, not just demonstrations, but violence that could have erupted.”
Protests flared up inside the Renolds Building as Lador-Fresher gave her speech and answered audience questions. Several activists in the audience stood and covered their faces with bandanas, which bore the emblem of the Israeli flag.
One prominent member of Action Palestine was cheered when he stood in front of the audience and held a Palestinian flag. He remained there for the duration of the debate.
Audience members shouted the word “rubbish” at the Deputy Ambassador when she claimed there was no humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Chants from protestors outside could be heard in the auditorium.
Student Direct: Mancunion asked the ambassador about campaigner’s calls to have certain members of the Israeli cabinet arrested under war crimes charges should they land on British soil. Lador-Fresher said: “I think both the Labour Party and the Tory party understand that issuing arrest warrants based on political whim is just ridiculous.
“If we were to find, god forbid, an Israeli terrorist or a Palestinian terrorist within our boarders we would arrest them yes, but these are two separate issues: one is a terrorist that you see, you know and you bring to justice, and another is a politician that due to public relations complaints, people want to arrest for crimes against humanity.”
With regards to the Palestine Solidarity movement Lador-Fresher said: “I think we have to educate and that’s part of why I’m coming here.
“Israel is an important strategic partner [for the UK] that’s not what just I think, your government thinks it too.
“I’m sorry to say that some people are unaware of some of the stories. They tend to say ‘well, if he is weak I’m with him’, to go with the underdog. But I must say it’s not always that the weak is right and the strong is wrong. Sometimes the stronger party can be the right party.”
“When the Deputy Ambassador for Israel came to our University to hold the rather ironically titled talk ‘Hopes and Challenges in the Middle East’, Action Palestine felt it was our duty to the Palestinian people, who are systematically oppressed by the government she represents, to protest against her cynical propaganda campaign,” said Patrick Cowling, a first year history student and member of Acton Palestine. Cowling was part of the protest that disrupted the ambassador’s speech.
Cowling continued: “Inside the hall, seven of us stood in silence throughout her talk and the Q&A session afterwards with Israeli flags tied around our mouths to symbolise the fact that whilst her ‘freedom of speech’ is being so passionately defended here in Manchester, the Palestinian people in Gaza, Israel and the occupied territories have no such luxury.
“Deputy Ambassador Lador-Fresher states that it is very important for her and the embassy to have the Israeli voice coming across to the young people of this country. Indeed it is, because Israel is desperately trying to claw back some respectability and restore its public image after the ruthless attack on Gaza last year.”
“But of course, as the Deputy Ambassador herself told us at the talk: there is no humanitarian crisis in Gaza. They have donkeys and Quality Street chocolates smuggled through the tunnels from Egypt, so this of course negates any humanitarian crisis in her eyes.
“The Deputy Ambassador failed to effectively answer many of the questions on Gaza and on the issues of the long list of violated UN resolutions. She put great emphasis on the UN resolution 181, which established the state of Israel, but seemed to miss the irony of the fact that her country is one of the leading violators of UN resolutions.”
Speaking after the event, Lador-Fresher said, “It was a thoroughly unpleasant experience. If this is what passes for debate at British universities, it really is a worrying state of affairs.”
“What is going on at British taxpayer-funded universities is shocking. Extremism is not just running through these places of education: it is galloping,” said Israeli Ambassador Ron Prosor. “My ears are ready and waiting to hear the strongest condemnation of this behaviour both from the heads of campus and the local authorities.”
A University of Manchester spokesperson said: “The University of Manchester is fundamentally committed to freedom of speech, exercised within the law. It follows that it should also allow peaceful and lawful protest to take place on its campus.
“The Deputy Israeli Ambassador was invited to speak by the Students’ Union Politics Society, and the University took all reasonable action to put appropriate security measures in place for this meeting, including a complete lockdown of the building, a high-level security presence, ID checks at the door and ticket-only arrangements.”